The Recs Bradley suggested to us that people get a thrill out of people getting away with things. When a “villain” (either fictional or real life) is well done, you become involved in a will-they-get-away-with-it. From soap baddies like JR Ewing in Dallas or Janine Butcher in EastEnders, a gleefully immoral rogue always catch the imagination and become the ones you love to hate.
Even more relevant here, the very premise of The Traitors incorporates the DNA of one of the most memorable pieces of reality show history. Say Big Brother and it won’t be long until someone mentions “Nasty” Nick Bateman. Rather than playing by the assumed rules, Bateman caused a stir in the first series of the British show by secretly pitting contestants against each other. The point where his fellow housemates sat him down and accused him of cheating was electrifying telly. Nick’s defence was he was playing the game.
The Traitors takes this kind of double-dealing behaviour and embeds it into their show. “We just need to play the game” declare The Traitors as they despatch contestants and pit the players against each other.
One of the reasons that this first season of The Traitors has taken a grip on the nation is because one of the chosen three traitors is the most inspired choice. Amanda is playing such a blinder, she’s beginning to scare us a little. She has brilliantly taken the group’s latent prejudice against her – that being the “Mum” of the group is the same as being Mumsy – and is using that for all its worth. Coupled with a lovely soft Welsh accent, the faithful have wrongly assumed that she is about as threatening as a mug of Horlicks. She has been publicly sympathetic when there is upset in the group. Hilariously, when a faithful revealed to the group that the traitors had tried to recruit her, Amanda went full moral indignation: “I think it’s a bloody cheek, I do”. As someone on Twitter succinctly said “Meryl Streep should be quaking in her boots”.
Three things need to happen.
One, Amanda must win – not least to see all their astonished faces.
Two, this show deserves to win ALL the awards going.
Three, can someone form a Traitors support group for when the show finishes next Thurday?