Things seem off from the start. The kitchen counters are overstuffed with appliances and supplies, the stove is covered with steaming pots and pans, and Eileen, the cranky matriarch of the clan, can’t stop being a contrarian, especially with Gilly, her unflappable daughter who’s insistent that the party happen.
Eileen: I hate soup. You know I hate soup. Gilly: I think you’ll like this one.
Eileen: Why, when in all of my ninety years, I’ve never liked soup, would I suddenly like this one?
Gilly: What’s wrong with soup? Eileen: It’s too wet.
Gilly wants to get the party started as soon as her daughter Jenny and granddaughter Muireann arrive from London, but Muireann has no interest in food, and Jenny insists they wait for her father before beginning.
Jenny: Mum. What about dad?
Gilly: What about him?
Jenny: We should wait for him to eat.
Gilly: We eat while it’s hot. Those are the rules. Now sit down.
Jenny: Did he say what time he’d be home?
Gilly: Who?
Playwright Karis Kelly has crafted a bold, and ambitious black comedy that tackles much in its brisk 70 minutes: intergenerational trauma, fraught mother-daughter bonds, and the long shadow of the Irish border. Under Katie Posner’s nimble direction, the play’s rhythm never falters, and this divine cast — Julia Dearden, Andrea Irvine, Caoimhe Farren and Muireann Ní Fhaogáin — could not be bettered.
Where the piece falters is in its final moments. After such sharp and carefully staged build-up, the ending feels abrupt, as though a vital scene or beat is missing. Up until then, this superb play is nearly flawless, and that makes the finale’s suddenness all the more jarring and noticeable. Kelly has already deservedly garnered one major prize for this play. With a touch more refinement, more accolades are certain to follow.