Scorched Earth – St Ann’s Warehouse ★★★★★

Digging Up the Dirt of ‘Scorched Earth’

Scorched Earth turns a cold case into something incendiary.

Writer, director, and choreographer Luke Murphy has created a hybrid of crime thriller and dance that is unpredictable and thought-provoking, and there is little question who the killer is in the murder being reinvestigated. Instead, Murphy focuses on property-based violence and the volatile emotions tied to the idea of ownership — who has the right to claim land, and how far they’ll go to keep it.

The victim: William Dean (Will Thompson), a newly arrived, rather confident property owner who outbids John McKay (Murphy) at auction for a stretch of land that McKay has tended with great care for several years. But the victory comes at a great cost, as Dean may have won the auction but in so doing lost his life that same evening. And one of his orange shoes.

The local authorities ruled the death an accident, but a decade later Detective Kerr (Sarah Dowling) reopens the case. Her interrogation sessions with McKay make up the bulk of the play, though not in a conventional form. Scenes seamlessly blend into each other, text and choreography accumulating toward a climactic coup de théâtre where the five cast members (Tyler Carney-Faleatua and Ryan O-Neil among them) dismantle Alyson Cummins’ striking set to reveal a steep green slope where the murder is re-enacted, in a style more intent on capturing emotion than uncovering fact.

Images by Teddy Wolff

In contrast to the heaviness of the material, the dancing is fluid, the dancers light on their feet. It’s an exciting juxtaposition that Murphy displays with great mastery, abetted by designers Stephen Dodd (lighting), Rob Moloney (composer and sound), Patricio Cassinoni (audio-visual) and Cummins, who also handled the costumes that include a life-size, eerie donkey and the titular earth.

The intense dances McKay has with a moving, twisting representation of the earth could have come across as too literal, but with this cast under Murphy’s assured direction, the thoughtful result is not only weirdly fascinating but also theatrically thrilling. Scorched Earth is an impressive achievement, another major win for St. Ann’s Warehouse, which is having a particularly strong season among the city’s Off-Broadway venues.   

A bold, physically charged investigation of land, memory, and violence ★★★★★ 5 stars

Scorched Earth Tickets

Scorched Earth runs at St Ann's Warehouse until 19 April 2026

Book Now

Author Profile

The Recs RDC - Randall David Cook