2:22: A Ghost Story – Lucille Lortel Theatre ★★★★★

‘2:22 A Ghost Story’: The House Is Haunted

2:22 A Ghost Story has, appropriately enough, two major assets that make it must-see theatre for those who like their stories on the spooky side. 

The first is Jasmine Cephas-Jones, who originated the role of Peggy, the third Schuyler sister in Hamilton. That juggernaut may have been her brassy introduction to a much wider audience, but here she proves she does not need to sing to earn her supper, demonstrating some serious dramatic chops as Jenny, a sleep-deprived first-time mother who is certain that her infant is being visited in the middle of the night by a ghost who lives in the house. Even in the wildest moments, she remains utterly credible, grounding both the production and the other fine actors around her at The Lucille Lortel Theatre.

Images by Evan Zimmerman

A terrific Finn Jones plays her arrogant astronomer husband, Sam, who’s been away on a trip to a remote island and has returned just in time for the scheduled dinner party with his college friend Lauren (Anna Camp, fearless), a psychotherapist who self-medicates with prescriptions and booze, and her new boyfriend Ben (Martin Marquez, excitingly intense), a blue-collar builder. Ben is fully aware that Lauren has unrequited feelings for her longtime school pal, and that Sam judges him and finds him wanting. But he’s a proud man, and knows things Sam does not.

In the baby’s bedroom there are nightly strange sounds, along with a window that keeps opening on its own, leading to spirited, engaging debates as Sam provokes his wife and dinner guests with skepticism about the possible existence of ghosts, much less one in his house. The quartet of quarrelers is joined by the offstage baby, whose coos and cries can be heard on the ever-present baby monitor, and by the titular ghost, who revs up the genuinely scary action as the clock ticks its way to 2:22 a.m.  

The second major asset of this wily horror-thriller is the superbly clever script by Danny Robins, brought wonderfully to life by directors Matthew Dunster and Gabriel Vega Weissman and the entire design team, especially the atmospheric lighting by Lucy Carter and creepy sound design by Ian Dickinson. Robins has crafted a work with wonderful twists and turns — and plenty of clues — that will have audience members long talking about what happened after their screams have died down and the actors have taken their deserved bows.

Jolting in all the right ways ★★★★★ 5 stars

2:22 A Ghost Story Off-Broadway Tickets

2:22 A Ghost Story runs at the Lucille Lortel Theatre until January 17, 2027

Book Now

Author Profile

The Recs RDC - Randall David Cook