If It’s A Sin had been released at another time, it might have been dismissed as ‘misery porn’. However, by an unforeseen quirk of timing, the show has acquired some striking contemporary resonances.
Remarkably for a period piece that was commissioned in 2018 and concluded filming in 31 January 2020, Russell T Davies’ story of AIDS in the UK has striking parallels to the current response to the Covid-19 crisis.
Both AIDS and Covid-19 first ping on people’s radar as something that is happening far away, in other countries, with little cause for concern. When the diseases finally hit our shores, initially what is known from a medical perspective is sketchy.
As it spreads and becomes more of a conscious threat to the wider public, ill-informed scare stories and conspiracy theories abound as well as people refusing to take it seriously.
How different is Ritchie’s Episode 2 railing against the “propaganda” than the disinformation spouted by Covid deniers. “It’s a moneymaking scheme for drugs companies” espouses Ritchie though it could quite easily be found by a Covidiot on Twitter. “They say it was created in a laboratory” he continues. Sound familiar? “How do I know it’s not true? Because I’m not stupid. Which means I don’t believe it.” He concludes that “that’s what they want you to think, that lot. They want to scare us, and stop us having sex and make us really boring basically because they can’t get laid“. Allison Pearson, Laurence Fox, and Julia Hartley-Brewer would be proud.
Beyond these parallels, the show has evoked a strong emotional response. Tweet after tweet, post after post, talks of crying their way through episodes, needing to steel themselves for a tough watch and being heartbroken by the end.